A smaller WebP file can still arrive too late
Compare visual quality, dimensions, discovery, and the delivered variant. Image compression fixes transfer size; it does not explain every loading delay or guarantee a ranking gain.

An image can lose half its bytes and still appear late. If the browser discovers it after a script runs, or the page delays rendering it, a smaller file fixes only part of the wait. Image optimisation needs a delivery check as well as an encoder.
WebP is one option in that work. Its usefulness depends on the actual image, the chosen settings, the displayed dimensions, and what the browser receives. The filename extension cannot establish either visual quality or a search-ranking improvement.
Compare the same image at a usable quality
Google's WebP overview reports compression gains over JPEG and PNG under specified comparisons. Those figures describe the cited tests. They are not a promise that every converted asset on a particular site will shrink by the same percentage.
Start from the original and encode a few candidates. Inspect photographs at their intended display size, paying attention to faces, fine texture, gradients, and edges. For screenshots or line drawings, check small text and hard colour boundaries. A quality setting with the same number in two encoders need not produce equivalent visible quality.
Compare dimensions too. Sending a very large image to a small screen can waste more bytes than the choice between two efficient formats saves. Preserve the original so that a later change in size or encoding does not begin with an already degraded file.
AVIF can be another candidate. Choose from the measured output and supported delivery requirements. A universal format hierarchy skips the content-specific comparison the site actually needs.
Find the image that controls the wait
The Largest Contentful Paint element may be an image or a text block. Inspect the measured page before assuming its hero illustration is the bottleneck. A slow server response or blocking resource can delay that element before image transfer becomes relevant.
web.dev's LCP guidance separates resource discovery, loading, and rendering concerns. It explicitly warns against lazy-loading the LCP image. An example intended for a prominent initial image should not contain a lazy-loading instruction merely because that attribute is useful elsewhere.
For a likely LCP image, make its URL discoverable in the initial HTML and consider an appropriate fetch-priority hint. For images genuinely outside the initial view, lazy loading may save work. Inspect the actual request sequence after the change; the browser's behaviour is the evidence.
Setting every image to high priority cannot make all of them first. It removes the distinction the hint was supposed to communicate. Reserve the hint for the resource that needs it.
Check the delivered variant
A conversion script succeeding locally does not prove that the page uses its output. Inspect the requested URL, response type, dimensions, and transfer size on desktop and mobile. Responsive markup can select a different source from the one a developer expected.
Supply image dimensions or a suitable aspect ratio so that space can be reserved before the asset arrives. Then check cropping. A lightweight image with the subject cut off is a failed delivery even if its performance score improves.
Treat the alternative text as content. Describe the image's purpose in the page; do not fill the attribute with search terms or repeat a caption mechanically. Decorative assets may need different treatment from images that carry information.
Separate performance evidence from ranking claims
Google's current page-experience explanation says Core Web Vitals are used by its ranking systems, while good scores do not guarantee top positions. A performance improvement can therefore be worthwhile without supplying a predictable SEO return.
Use repeatable lab checks to diagnose a change, then examine real-user measurements when enough data is available. Record the page, device conditions, and date. A single favourable run should not become a claim about every visitor's experience.
If the image is smaller but LCP is unchanged, inspect the remaining delay before converting the whole library. The next useful change may be earlier discovery, a better size choice, or less render-blocking work. Choose the fix from the measured wait, then keep the image good enough to do its job.