An AI merge resolution still has to preserve both changes
A clean merge can contain a broken program. Review an AI proposal against each branch's intended behavior and test the interaction that caused the conflict.

Two branches change the same function. One adds an authorization check. The other changes how the response is built. A merged function can look tidy and pass a syntax check while losing the authorization behavior. Removing conflict markers is only the first visible part of the job.
AI assistance can propose a combined version and reduce manual editing. The review still needs to ask what each branch intended to preserve. Otherwise a plausible implementation can choose one branch's behavior while appearing to integrate both.
This is a distinction Git itself makes. Its merge-conflict guide discusses semantic conflicts, where the combined program can be wrong even when textual changes merge cleanly. A tool's ability to produce unmarked text does not establish the behavior of the resulting program.
Reconstruct the reason for each change
Before accepting a proposal, inspect each branch's change relative to the common base. The base explains what both authors started from. A side-by-side view of only the final branch versions can hide whether a line was deliberately removed or simply left unchanged.
For the authorization example, identify the condition that should deny access. Then identify the response change the other branch intended. The merged result needs to preserve that denial behavior while producing the intended response for permitted requests. Those requirements can be stated before deciding which code looks most natural.
VS Code's current merge documentation includes an AI-assisted resolution flow. The proposal remains something the developer can inspect in the editor. Feature availability and the chosen configuration should be checked in the actual installation, with no assumption that a subscription price or an old interface description still applies.
Give the assistant the relevant surrounding code when it is available. If the function calls a helper whose behavior changed elsewhere, that dependency belongs in the review. A correct-looking hunk can still call an interface that the combined branch no longer provides.
Test the interaction that could be lost
A formatter can make the function consistent with repository style. A type check can catch certain interface errors. Neither substitutes for exercising the authorization case that motivated the change. Use a test that would fail if the merged function permitted the denied request.
Then check the permitted path affected by the response change. This prevents a resolution from preserving the denial condition by breaking ordinary use. The two changes determine which cases need to be tested.
The scope of the final diff also needs inspection. An assistant may change code outside the marked conflict because the integration requires it. That broader change deserves a reason and appropriate verification. Automatically rejecting every extra line can prevent a correct integration, while accepting unexplained edits hides additional risk.
For generated files, inspect the source that produces them. Resolving a generated output by hand can leave it inconsistent with the next generation run. Where the repository defines a regeneration process, use that process and review the resulting diff under the project's normal rules.
A benchmark result has a defined unit
Research now offers more evidence than a collection of demonstrations. The 2026 Merge-Bench paper describes a dataset of 7,938 conflict hunks from 1,439 GitHub repositories. That gives researchers a defined collection for studying candidate resolutions. It does not make a result on an individual hunk equivalent to acceptance of a complete application release.
When comparing tools, check how correctness is judged. Matching a historical resolution answers one question. Passing relevant behavioral tests answers another. A historical resolution may contain choices a developer made for reasons outside the hunk, so a numerical match rate needs its evaluation method beside it.
A team's own pilot should use representative conflicts with known acceptance conditions. Include a case where a clean textual merge leaves a behavioral problem elsewhere. Otherwise the pilot can favor tools that make the editor look resolved while missing the integration work the team actually needs.
Reuse a resolution without forgetting its context
Git's rerere facility can record a conflict resolution and reuse it when the same conflict appears again. This can save repeated work without asking a model to invent another proposal. The reused result still needs review in its new surrounding context.
A helper may have changed since the original resolution. A previously correct combination can therefore need a different test today. Reuse preserves an earlier edit; it cannot certify every later dependency.
For the next conflict, write the behavior each side contributes before accepting the combined code. Review the final diff against those requirements and run the tests that exercise their interaction. The merge is ready when that evidence supports the resulting program.